CASE STUDY 2 – PLAN FOR AND SUPPORT STUDENT LEARNING THROUGH APPROPRIATE APPROACHES AND ENVIRONMENTS

Written by

in

Presenting student work offsite from UAL throws up a range of challenges, those around appropriateness of environment are some of the sharpest. UAL holds its spaces to a higher standard of physical accessibility than is legally required; where these standards begin and end and if they apply to offsite working are an open, contested question. 

A good practical example of this was an offsite show of Painting student work at South London Gallery (SLG). SLG has two spaces, one of which had significant accessibility challenges. Dilston Grove is a listed building, and was the first ever concrete building in Britain. However, this early concrete coupled with its many years as a ruin mean the floor is very uneven, especially the raised rear of the former church, which is accessed by four worn down and uneven steps. One of the students was a wheelchair user, but beyond this, multiple students raised the general principal of accessibility and of showing in accessible spaces. This raised a complex set of questions about accessibility principals, diffuse responsibilities and cost bearing. Broadly: can or should off-site shows be held to the same standard of step-free accessibility as we have at UAL sites; if so, who is responsible for ensuring off-site space accessibility; and finally, if so who pays the cost of ensuring that accessibility?

The challenge was that, if the first principal was kept to, then UAL should not be showing in the SLG at all – Dilston Grove is listed meaning no permanent modifications could be made, for example spending money for the install of a permanent ramp, or levelling out the floor. Changing space was not a decision that could be made in the install week. So, if the show was to go ahead in this non-accessible space, who was then responsible for ensuring adjustments for accessibility? The SLG team argued UAL were, as no previous hirer of the space had raised this issue. The Painting staff argued the Projects & Showcase team (my team) were, as we were producing the overall show. We argued that we had no say in the choice of off-site space, and would not have hired a non-accessible space. Ultimately, this hot potato fell on the SLG team and a portable single storey wheelchair lift was hired, at great expense, to ensure access to the raised area at the rear.

In my assessment, this was an unsatisfactory solution for all parties involved, and has clear lessons for the future. Firstly, UAL staff should either only hire spaces that meet an agreed accessibility criteria, or have a clear ‘party line’ on what the exceptions are – for example showing in a completely unique space such as Dilston Grove. Secondly, wherever possible curatorial mitigations to accessibility should be found – for example in this instance, no wall-mounted work could have been displayed in the raised section, only sculptural work that could be approached from a distance of a couple of metres. Thirdly, specific accessibility needs should be identified wherever possible by tutoring staff in advance – in this instance, the hiring cost would have been much lower if booked months in advance, and that lower cost could have easily been shared between SLG and UAL. And finally, a lesson more for SLG than UAL is to have a better contract – I have been in their position in previous jobs and though ensuring that needs for accessibility adjustments were mentioned in the contract I have had clear protocols for this situation, for example the venue researching solutions that are paid for by the hirer. 

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *