I have been thinking about feedback, especially in the context of of a multicultural institution like UAL. This lead me to read Sadler’s Beyond feedback: developing student capability
in complex appraisal. Sadler discusses in depth complexities around giving and receiving actionable feedback. For example, the issues around written feedback as a form of asynchronous communication, where the form and tone of the response must be second guessed in advance to ensure it is taken in by the student rather than rejected. Sadler’s idea of the fundamental issue of the knowledge gap between marking staff and students was interesting, though I would extend the concept beyond specialist subject knowledge to wider cultural knowledge. For example, I remember explaining to a course mate from another country while doing my masters how British university marking works, and how they might translate what to them looked like a failing mark purely based on its’ numerical value.
Sadler identifies peer assessment as a very efficient way to generate actionable feedback, describing a model where students are given a framework to mark and be marked by each other consisting of four wide ranging questions on the success of the execution of the work. This peer assessment model chimed with my experience of the microteaching exercise, if we treat the session as a piece of work. The conclusions that were drawn by my peers were immediately, concretely actionable. Given my experience of the success of peer assessment, I would want to use this model in my work with students – for example accompanying me when I check over installed work for safety, and turning it into a kind of rolling discursive seminar. Of course, this would be much less time efficient as a model – it would need to be built in to an exhibition from the start.
References
Royce Sadler, D. ‘Beyond Feedback: Developing Student Capability in Complex Appraisal’. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 2010, 535–50.
Leave a Reply