Category: REFLECTIVE BLOGS

  • REFLECTIVE BLOG 4 – BRIEFS

    The lecture discussion on learning outcomes made me reflect on my experiences with briefs in further eduction, and the tensions around them in higher education. When undertaking my masters I found learning outcomes and marking criteria incredibly useful reference material throughout the whole process. I treated them essentially as briefs for a series of commercial jobs. I found that as I was studying alongside working full time, this was the only way to efficiently use the fixed and limited time I had for my studies and prevent me using this time on interesting, though not relevant, outputs. However, from speaking to my peers at the time and students at UAL now, this approach seems to be unusual. There seems to be a more general sense of luxuriation in process, or following intuition blindly until you find what you didn’t know what you were looking for, creatively speaking.

    Both approaches are legitimate. I’ve also noticed this tension when discussing this with colleagues at UAL – there is often a sense that students come to UAL wanting space to develop rather than proscriptive employability skills. However I feel that as part of creative arts eduction, teaching our students how to follow a brief and create usable deliverables is a great, practical skill for future creative careers. This cuts right to the heart of the question of what art school eduction is for – developing creative expression or learning how to have a creative career.

  • REFLECTIVE BLOG 3 – RELATIONAL AESTHETICS

    Thought this my study on this module, I have been thinking about the potential applicability of a relational aesthetics framework to art teaching. Broadly, Nicolas Bourriaud’s theory of relational aesthetics states that the artwork is what exists in the relational space between the audience, artist and art-object. It has struck me that learning, especially in a seminar or art crit environment, could be read in the same way – as a process in which the creative or generative part exists in the fourth, relational space between the others. Of course this mirrors to an extent the dialectic or socratic method, where the learning comes from the student answering their own questions rather than being told the answer; however a relational aesthetics model fully accounts for multiple people in the same space drawing equally from the new object that is crated, learning. 

    I have previous experience with applying relational aesthetic principals to both gallery public program work and to my own sound art practice, and have found it immensely useful in both contexts. For example, analysing improvised performance as an object that exists between the performer, the performance and the audience, rather than a directional one way act from performer to audience. Also, practically, I have found it a very useful lens to discuss installed work with students – how their work creates a context that an audience exists in to create the overall aesthetic experience. This is often more useful than language around staging or framing as it moves students beyond visual language and towards a deeper understanding of what art can be.

    References

    Bourriaud, Nicolas. Relational Aesthetics. Les Presses Du Reel, 2002.

  • REFLECTIVE BLOG 2 – FEEDBACK

    I have been thinking about feedback, especially in the context of of a multicultural institution like UAL. This lead me to read Sadler’s Beyond feedback: developing student capability

    in complex appraisal. Sadler discusses in depth complexities around giving and receiving actionable feedback. For example, the issues around written feedback as a form of asynchronous communication, where the form and tone of the response must be second guessed in advance to ensure it is taken in by the student rather than rejected. Sadler’s idea of the fundamental issue of the knowledge gap between marking staff and students was interesting, though I would extend the concept beyond specialist subject knowledge to wider cultural knowledge. For example, I remember explaining to a course mate from another country while doing my masters how British university marking works, and how they might translate what to them looked like a failing mark purely based on its’ numerical value. 

    Sadler identifies peer assessment as a very efficient way to generate actionable feedback, describing a model where students are given a framework to mark and be marked by each other consisting of four wide ranging questions on the success of the execution of the work. This peer assessment model chimed with my experience of the microteaching exercise, if we treat the session as a piece of work. The conclusions that were drawn by my peers were immediately, concretely actionable. Given my experience of the success of peer assessment, I would want to use this model in my work with students – for example accompanying me when I check over installed work for safety, and turning it into a kind of rolling discursive seminar. Of course, this would be much less time efficient as a model – it would need to be built in to an exhibition from the start. 

    References

    Royce Sadler, D. ‘Beyond Feedback: Developing Student Capability in Complex Appraisal’. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 2010, 535–50.

  • REFLECTIVE BLOG 1 – FIRST STEPS

    In our first session, by chance I ended up sitting with technical staff from other UAL colleges, with a range of specialisms and scopes of work. We had all undertaken the same reading, Sams’ How do art and design technicians conceive of their role in higher education? This was a useful jumping off point for a wide ranging conversation about the non-standardised approach to technical & support work at UAL, for example how colleagues on older contracts are sometimes entitled to research budgets and time off the attend gallery openings – contractual elements not available to newer colleagues. We also discussed the unclear and unevenly applied regulations about what support work counts as ‘teaching’, and the frequent frustration around this imperceptible but firmly enforced tipping point. We also discussed my reading of a gap in Sams’ writing; to me, the majority of the issues or frustrations she outlines are commonalities with most knowledge based work in the uk, those of a general alienation from one’s labour, and increasing responsibility/seniority reducing the ratio of time spent on the fulfilling parts of the role – in this case directly helping students.

    Additionally, Sams’ research methodology was interesting, especially the use of photography as a conversational object. By interacting with a photograph, the technicians were able to relate to their own work or employment as an outside object, gaining an additional, potentially more objective angle, on their role within the university. I intend to use this model in my forthcoming microteaching session – at this stage I’m thinking of looking at tools, and thinking about the commonalities and divergences in the primary tools we use to produce work, building on my on experience researching embodied performance practices and finding out how applicable that model is to other colleagues’ work and self-conception as practitioners.