UNIT 2, BLOG 2 – BELIEF

Written by

in

When I encounter faith or belief at work, it is almost always political beliefs rather than religious beliefs. Political beliefs and belief systems can function as religious or philosophical beliefs, and having no religion or belief has the same legal partitions in the UK.1 Especially  when considering international students, the British state’s framing of belief may not fit with that of their home polity. 

Working on the degree shows across Chelsea, Camberwell and Wimbledon, I get to see the majority of degree show work produced by students at the three collages, across all courses. One of the common themes that surprised me when I fist state at UAL was work by students from the People’s Republic of China (hereafter PRC) reflecting on their relationship to what you could broadly class as liberalism. Often, the work reflects what they had felt as freedom of personal expression they felt they had experienced while living and studying in the UK, and contrasts it with their perceived limits and ‘chilling factors’ on self-expression in the PRC. 

This self-expression must also been seen in context of “transnational repression” of PRC students and their families back home by security services.2 Amnesty International produced a wide ranging report in 2024 looking at intimidatory tactics faced by students from the PRC & Hong Kong after taking part in protected speech activities in the uk, such as commemorating the 1989 Tiananmen Square protests or Hong Kong pro-democracy protests of the 2010s. Interestingly, none of the students interviewed by Amnesty International were art students. I also spoke to some friends from the PRC, former art students, who also told me they hadn’t experienced these kind of tactics or threats. From this we me may be able to infer that PRC state services care primarily about governmental critique, rather than pro-liberal or personal, interior expression. 

On one level then, UAL seems to be functioning as a safe place to express these ideas for students from the PRC. But, there may be a chilling effect taking place – students producing work they know is at the limit of ‘safe’ critique.

On one level, this can be seen as a free speech issue – but it rarely feat in discussions of free speech in higher education. For example, it is not discussed once in the government’s 2021 report that became the 2023 Higher Education (Freedom of Speech act), the current freedom of speech framework which UAL operates in.3. In a sense there is a conflict between two systems – the UK’s long-standing apparatus around protected characteristics, and the transnational efforts of the PRC government to create a chilling effect on free speech for students in the west. I personally think there is no obvious route through this knotty issue, but on a personal level, I can continue to support students in the execution of their work, and follow their lead in any discussion of ideas around liberalism and free speech. 

References

ACAS. ‘Religion or Belief Discrimination: What the Law Says’. 29 October 2024. https://www.acas.org.uk/religion-or-belief-discrimination.

Amnesty International. “ON MY CAMPUS, I AM AFRAID”: CHINA’S TARGETING OF OVERSEAS STUDENTS STIFLES RIGHTS. Amnesty International, 2024.

Amnesty International. ‘UK: Chinese and Hong Kong Students in UK Live in Fear from Long-Arm of Chinese Government’. 12 May 2024. https://www.amnesty.org.uk/latest/uk-chinese-and-hong-kong-students-uk-live-fear-long-arm-chinese-government/.

Dragoș, Simina, and Taylor A. Hughson. ‘Furthering Racial Liberalism in UK Higher Education: The Populist Construction of the “Free Speech Crisis”’. The British Journal of Sociology 75, no. 4 (2024): 636–49. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-4446.13119.

Higher Education: Free Speech and Academic Freedom. Dandy Booksellers Ltd, 2021.

Zhou, Mengxing. ‘Cross-Cultural Learning Experiences of Chinese International Students in a UK University: A Qualitative Study’. Frontiers in Education Volume 11-2026 (2026). https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/education/articles/10.3389/feduc.2026.1824782.

  1. ACAS. ‘Religion or Belief Discrimination: What the Law Says’. 29 October 2024. https://www.acas.org.uk/religion-or-belief-discrimination. ↩︎
  2. Amnesty International. “ON MY CAMPUS, I AM AFRAID”: CHINA’S TARGETING OF OVERSEAS STUDENTS STIFLES RIGHTS. Amnesty International, 2024. ↩︎
  3. Higher Education: Free Speech and Academic Freedom. Dandy Booksellers Ltd, 2021. ↩︎

Comments

2 responses to “UNIT 2, BLOG 2 – BELIEF”

  1. Ilia avatar
    Ilia

    Good observation! Would like to also chip-in my observation. Students from PRC are not a monolith and I do suspect there are cultural and political dynamics in-play that are too obscure for outside observers to parse. As a student I definitely did hear some anecdotal stories about friction between pro and anti CCP students.

    1. George Rayner-Law avatar
      George Rayner-Law

      Thanks Ilia, I definitely agree there are dynamics that are not visible to non-chinese people at UAL. One of the challenges I had in the academic literature is there is very little research on art students from china rather than STEM students – maybe they have a different relation to culture and politics? We don’t have any hard evidence either way frustratingly. I did some helpful reading on the development of art schools in the PRC 1949 – present to help situate my understanding, but wasn’t able to include it in this short blog. For example, the move away from a model of stalinist ‘socialist realism’ in the 90s.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *